The Problem With Birth Control Pills

Before I dive into the details of this post, I want to make very clear that this post is not meant to judge or shame anyone for their contraceptive choice. This is a very personal topic, and my goal is simply to present some of the less-talked-about health risks created by hormonal birth control. I am a firm believer in empowering women to make educated and informed health choices that align with their values, and if The Pill helps you live authentically, then I’m all about that. I just want you to have all the information that you rightfully deserve. The purpose of this post is to share knowledge that you may find helpful when considering your own reproductive health, whether you choose to use birth control pills or not.

Please note: When referring to hormonal contraceptives, birth control pills or “the pill” in this post, I am referencing medications containing both estrogen and progesterone analogs (estradiol and progestin).

The menstrual cycle plays a powerful role in women’s health, and not just in terms of fertility. As I shared in this post, our periods tell us way much more about our sense of well-being than whether or not we’re pregnant, and that information is so, so important! If our cycle is out of sync, it’s really important for us to address those concerns early so that the underlying causes–like thyroid, metabolic, adrenal, or other hormone imbalances–don’t worsen and lead to disease.

Masking the Root Cause

Because of their ability to give us early warning signs about our health, our periods are referred to as our “fifth vital sign” along with heart rate, blood pressure, temperature, and breathing rate. When it comes to our cycles, deviations from the norm often signify an underlying health concern that will intensify, eventually leading to a more serious problem. For example, most chronic illnesses that we see today are either triggered or worsened by stress. Even if a person isn’t experiencing a flare up of their chronic symptoms (or maybe they have a genetic predisposition that hasn’t yet manifested), our bodies can send us warning signals that our stress is reaching a critical level through changes to our menstrual cycles. Stress interrupts the delicate web of signals between our brains and the organs that secrete our hormones (sex hormones, thyroid hormones, metabolic hormones, and more) leading to missing, painful, or irregular cycles. (For more about the details of what your period can tell you about your health, check out this post.)

Birth Control Pills Shut Down Our Natural Hormonal Processes

I explain the nitty-gritty details of what happens during the menstrual cycle in this post. But as a quick refresher, the main event of our menstrual cycle isn’t the bleed, but rather it is ovulation–the release of an egg. The first two weeks of the cycle are all about ramping up the hormonal signals (mainly estrogen) required to mature and release an egg so that your body can become pregnant. After ovulation, progesterone takes over, preparing the uterus to become a suitable environment for a growing baby if the egg meets a sperm along its journey through the fallopian tube. As you learned in sex ed, the egg passes through if it isn’t fertilized, and the uterine lining sheds away. This shedding of menstrual blood–your period–marks day one of the next cycle.

Birth control pills are made up of chemicals that resemble estrogen and progesterone, overriding your body’s natural signaling pathways. Their purpose is to prevent the release of an egg while still allowing your body to “go through the motions” (i.e. by thickening and shedding the uterine lining every 28 days.) While it might seem easier to just not have a period at all, the processes that take place during your cycle are about more than fertility, and shutting them down completely would be very dangerous, leading to osteoporosis, heart disease, and other health problems. So in lieu of completely eliminating your period, the pill shuts off the “main event” of your cycle, aka ovulation, while setting up a carefully curated hormonal environment that mimics a healthy period.

Except it isn’t a healthy menstrual cycle because it isn’t a menstrual cycle at all. It’s just a bleed. Without being able to control their own hormonal fluctuations, our bodes lose their ability to communicate with us about our hormonal health status.

Because of the way that the false periods induced by birth control pills so closely resemble healthy cycles, the pill is often prescribed for reasons other than contraception. Patient suffering from hormonal acne, PMS, painful periods, PCOS, and other women’s health conditions are often given birth control pills because it seems to solve these problems. But the root cause of these issues goes much deeper, and the pill simply masks over the real issue. It’s kind of like breaking your toe and “curing” the problem by chopping off your whole leg. It completely misses the point. Your toe stops hurting, but only because you don’t have one anymore! The same is true of using the pill for non-contraceptive purposes. Your period seems normal but only because you aren’t really having your cycle anymore! As a result, the underlying cause is left to fester, and often returns with a vengeance as soon as you come off the pill. This was exactly what happened to me, as I shared in this post about my experience with hypothalamic amenorrhea caused by chronic dieting.

Health Risks

In addition to masking over our health problems, the pill often outright creates health risks of its own. Here are just a few:

  • Infertility: Despite being often marketed as a “fertility drug,” the pill does not support the optimal function of the female body. It actually does the opposite, by shutting off reproductive function and inhibiting ovulation. Unfortunately, many women struggle with fertility problems even after they discontinue use of the pill. It’s not as if ovulation magically starts up again after being chemically prevented. It takes time for the body to re-learn how to secrete hormones in a balanced and functional way. Sometimes, the body can’t reach that place post-pill on its own without medical support.
  • Hormone Imbalances: Even if ovulation resumes, many women find that they struggle with metabolic, thyroid, adrenal, or other hormonal imbalances outside of fertility upon coming off the pill. As I describe in this post, our various hormonal systems are all interrelated, so when we so drastically interfere with one aspect of the HPATG axis (as is the case with the pill), other bodily systems can become imbalanced too. Symptoms like fatigue, weight gain, thinning hair, insomnia, and more can all point back to hormonal contraceptive use, or discontinued use.
  • Blood Clots: A widely known fact in the medical community that is seldom talked about in a clinical setting is that oral contraceptives containing estrogen or estrogen analogs increase the risk of blood clots forming, even in otherwise healthy women with no underlying conditions. While certain factors increase risk of this phenomenon (smoking, being over 35 years of age, prolonged inactivity, and family history), the likelihood of blood clots goes up dramatically for all women. These blood clots form in deep veins of the body (most often the legs), and if they break off, they can become lodged in the heart (causing a heart attack), lungs (causing a pulmonary embolism) or brain (causing a stroke). This risk is increased even if a woman follows a healthy lifestyle. [Note: Blood clots from using oral contraceptives is often presented as a low risk, but it’s not really that low. Different sources say different things, but it’s typically discussed about as being about 1/1,000, or 0.1%. Let’s add some context…the CDC estimates that 28% of US women are currently using oral contraceptives, which is about 10.6 million women. I’ll let you do the math, but 0.1% of 10.6 million isn’t a small number—and it seems even larger when it’s someone you know. I personally know of three women in from my own personal life (not even counting patients) who experienced this in their twenties.]
  • Heart Disease: Long-term exposure to hormonal analogs like those found in the pill act like a biochemical source of stress in the body. These chronic stress exposures alter the metabolism of lipids and carbohydrates in the body, raising blood cholesterol and triglycerides and increasing risk of chronic disease, especially heart disease in women. Once again, this is true even for otherwise healthy individuals.
  • Increased risk of some cancers—namely breast and cervical cancer. Breast cancer is the number one most common type of cancer among women, and cervical cancer is the fourth most common type of cancer in women, worldwide.
  • Insulin Resistance: One of the ways that oral contraceptives affect metabolism is by increasing blood glucose levels and subsequent insulin secretion. With time, this can increase risk of insulin resistance and the development of metabolic syndrome and/or diabetes.
  • Gallbladder and Liver Dysfunction: Part of the role of the liver and gallbladder in our health is to detoxify our bodies from old, broken down hormones, red blood cells, and other waste products. This is a natural and normal process, but sometimes it can become overloaded if the amount of waste buildup is higher than the normal capacity of these organs. Sex hormones like estrogen are one of the major substrates of the liver and gallbladder, and can “clog up” the system leading to low-grade damage. Some women who experience this manifest skin reactions like itching, rashes, or yellowing of the skin (jaundice).

Female Empowerment

It still blows my mind that so many important women’s health topics are still taboo. Sure, sex is a private matter, but healthcare information shouldn’t be limited or kept secret. As women, we deserve to understand our bodies, including the implications of the medical interventions we receive. Ovulation and menstruation are normal and necessary parts of a healthy woman’s body if she is of reproductive age, and these functions (or lack thereof) give us valuable insight into our well-being. They don’t need to be shut off, and we don’t need to be quiet about it.

Our level of understanding of the female body in science doesn’t require us to subdue our femininity in order to allow us to make family planning decisions in accordance with our values. Likewise, we deserve better medicine—safe and effective, individualized treatment plans that address the root cause of symptoms, whether in terms of our reproductive health or otherwise. If the birth control pill fits your goals and values for your life, that’s awesome! I totally support you. But I also want you to know that if it doesn’t, there are other options for you that protect your health and your values, and which allow you to make informed decisions on behalf of both your family and your own body.

Censorship of these conversations limits a woman’s access to essential information about her sense of well-being. Sexual health isn’t gross or weird, and it shouldn’t be hush-hush. In fact, every single person on earth is only here because of the function of a woman’s reproductive system. The female body is amazing, and each of us should have the privilege of understanding it on a personal level, especially when making the very personal decision about whether or not to use hormonal contraceptives.


One thought on “The Problem With Birth Control Pills

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s